independent and unofficial
Prince fan community site
Wed 3rd Dec 2008 10:26pm
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Politics & Religion > The film "Towelhead"
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  Create new topic   Printable version   (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
AuthorMessage
Thread started 08/27/08 11:18pm

Mars23

avatar

The film "Towelhead"

From IMDB:

Warner Bros. has rejected a demand by the Council on American Islamic Relations to change the title of its forthcoming movie Towelhead to its original title, Nothing Is Private. Cair had objected that "the use of such a derogatory term by a major film studio will serve to increase its acceptability in public discourse." Towelhead, however, is the title of the novel by Arab-American Alicia Erian on which which the screenplay -- which she also wrote -- is based. In an interview with Reuters, Erian said she had used the racial slur in the title "to highlight one of the novel's major themes, racism." And in a commentary posted on the Cinematical website, critic Eric D. Snider, addressed Cair's protest this way: "Could it be that one of the movie's messages is that slurs like that are unacceptable? Could it be that only the most bigoted and idiotic of viewers could come out of it thinking, 'I'm gonna start sayin' "towelhead" more often!'?"


Towelhead follows the dark, bold and shockingly funny life of Jasira, a 13-year-old Arab-American girl, as she navigates the confusing and frightening path of adolescence and her own sexual awakening.

When Jasira's mother sends her to Houston to live with her strict Lebanese father, she quickly learns that her new neighbors find her and her father a curiosity. Worse, her budding womanhood makes her traditional and hot-tempered father uncomfortable. Lonely in this new environment, Jasira seeks friendship and acceptance from her neighbors Mr. Vuoso, an Army reservist, and Melina, a meddling but caring expectant mother.

Thrown into an unfamiliar suburban world, Jasira must confront racism and hypocrisy at home and at school - and at the same time struggle to make sense of her raging hormones and newfound sexuality. Her boyfriend, Thomas, though a few years older, provides some comfort - but even that relationship causes problems when her father discovers that Thomas is black. Surrounded by adults who are just as lost as she is, Jasira yearns for understanding, even amidst often brutal acts.

http://www.imdb.com/title...3873833241" target="_blank">
http://www.imdb.com/title...3873833241


So the novel was named "Towelhead" but the author changed it when the screenplay was written. It is unclear who made the decision to change the name of the film.

I tend to agree that things like this do challenge people to confront topics head on. I would have never read Randall Kennedy's book "Nigger" had the title not confronted me in the bookstore. Something about this smacks of publicity for some reason. Most likely the author's decision to change the name, then the change back.

While I don't think anyone that regularly uses the term will go see this movie unless they get a serious dose of misinformation regarding the content, I don't think the intended audience gains anything by the title change either.

What do you think? Good idea or publicity stunt?
[Edited 8/28/08 1:15am]

Join the antithesis of the org conservative union!

The "Lies Make Baby Jesus Cry Club" is now accepting applications!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 08/28/08 12:58am

NancyMoonbeam

avatar

Mars23 said:

From IMDB:

Warner Bros. has rejected a demand by the Council on American Islamic Relations to change the title of its forthcoming movie Towelhead to its original title, Nothing Is Private. Cair had objected that "the use of such a derogatory term by a major film studio will serve to increase its acceptability in public discourse." Towelhead, however, is the title of the novel by Arab-American Alicia Erian on which which the screenplay -- which she also wrote -- is based. In an interview with Reuters, Erian said she had used the racial slur in the title "to highlight one of the novel's major themes, racism." And in a commentary posted on the Cinematical website, critic Eric D. Snider, addressed Cair's protest this way: "Could it be that one of the movie's messages is that slurs like that are unacceptable? Could it be that only the most bigoted and idiotic of viewers could come out of it thinking, 'I'm gonna start sayin' "towelhead" more often!'?"



So the novel was named "Towelhead" but the author changed it when the screenplay was written. It is unclear who made the decision to change the name of the film.

I tend to agree that things like this do challenge people to confront topics head on. I would have never read Randall Kennedy's book "Nigger" had the title not confronted me in the bookstore. Something about this smacks of publicity for some reason. Most likely the author's decision to change the name, then the change back.

While I don't think anyone that regularly uses the term will go see this movie unless they get a serious dose of misinformation regarding the content, I don't think the intended audience gains anything by the title change either.

What do you think? Good idea or publicity stunt?


I dont know what the film is about so a little hard to comment -- it will certainly boost interest though I guess ?

If your the sort of person that would use the expression 'towelhead' or 'raghead' (It's UK equivilant) then watching a film will probably not have any effect wither way ?

"when one person suffers from a delusion it is called insanity. When many people suffer from a delusion it is called religion."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 08/28/08 6:56am

KoolEaze

avatar

Mars23 said:

From IMDB:






I tend to agree that things like this do challenge people to confront topics head on. I would have never read Randall Kennedy's book "Nigger" had the title not confronted me in the bookstore. Something about this smacks of publicity for some reason. Most likely the author's decision to change the name, then the change back.

While I don't think anyone that regularly uses the term will go see this movie unless they get a serious dose of misinformation regarding the content, I don't think the intended audience gains anything by the title change either.

What do you think? Good idea or publicity stunt?
[Edited 8/28/08 1:15am]



See, there´s your argument.Sometimes,the more provocative title is more helpful when it comes to attracting listeners,viewers or readers.
Then again, I can understand their reasoning that the more you use derogatory expressions,the more they become "legit" and acceptable in some way.
Reminds me of Nas´ " Nigger " album scandal.
It´s a thin line,really.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 08/28/08 7:55am

jone70

avatar

Mars23 said:

From IMDB:
I would have never read Randall Kennedy's book "Nigger" had the title not confronted me in the bookstore.



I thought Dick Gregory wrote that book. confuse (I'm too lazy to look up and see if there is really a book by that title by Randall Kennedy.)

The check. The string he dropped. The Mona Lisa. The musical notes taken out of a hat. The glass. The toy shotgun painting. The things he found. Therefore, everything seen–every object, that is, plus the process of looking at it–is a Duchamp.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 08/28/08 8:17am

Byron

jone70 said:

Mars23 said:

From IMDB:
I would have never read Randall Kennedy's book "Nigger" had the title not confronted me in the bookstore.



I thought Dick Gregory wrote that book. confuse (I'm too lazy to look up and see if there is really a book by that title by Randall Kennedy.)

He did nod...Nigger: An Autobiography.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 08/28/08 8:33am

jone70

avatar

Byron said:

jone70 said:




I thought Dick Gregory wrote that book. confuse (I'm too lazy to look up and see if there is really a book by that title by Randall Kennedy.)

He did nod...Nigger: An Autobiography.


It's a great book. I was in speech & drama in high school and did a prose interpretation of one of the chapters--the one where he talks about shame, being 'not poor, just broke', and how he had a crush on the little girl who was clean.

Ooh! I found it online: http://www.angelfire.com/...broke.html

Ironically, I never knew the 'real' title of the book it came from when I was in high school; I thought it was titled "Not Poor Just Broke." My speech coach cut the speech so that you couldn't even tell what race the characters were, so I never even knew Dick Gregory was black! I guess the he thought it would be less controversial in an all white town to not use the n* word, and focus on shame/poverty, which can affect anyone. After college I looked everywhere for that book, "Not Poor, Just Broke" by Dick Gregory and couldn't find it anywhere! lol (Since I didn't know my "not poor, just broke" Dick Gregory was black, I always thought the author of N*gger must be someone different.) Then one day my (then) boyfriend was reading N*gger and told me I should read it because it was a good book. So I did and I found the speech in there! biggrin

The check. The string he dropped. The Mona Lisa. The musical notes taken out of a hat. The glass. The toy shotgun painting. The things he found. Therefore, everything seen–every object, that is, plus the process of looking at it–is a Duchamp.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 08/28/08 9:00am

Byron

jone70 said:

Byron said:


He did nod...Nigger: An Autobiography.


It's a great book. I was in speech & drama in high school and did a prose interpretation of one of the chapters--the one where he talks about shame, being 'not poor, just broke', and how he had a crush on the little girl who was clean.

Ooh! I found it online: http://www.angelfire.com/...broke.html

Ironically, I never knew the 'real' title of the book it came from when I was in high school; I thought it was titled "Not Poor Just Broke." My speech coach cut the speech so that you couldn't even tell what race the characters were, so I never even knew Dick Gregory was black! I guess the he thought it would be less controversial in an all white town to not use the n* word, and focus on shame/poverty, which can affect anyone. After college I looked everywhere for that book, "Not Poor, Just Broke" by Dick Gregory and couldn't find it anywhere! lol (Since I didn't know my "not poor, just broke" Dick Gregory was black, I always thought the author of N*gger must be someone different.) Then one day my (then) boyfriend was reading N*gger and told me I should read it because it was a good book. So I did and I found the speech in there! biggrin

falloff lol...Yeah, I was wondering how you pulled that off in your high school from everything you've said about where you grew up lol smile...

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 08/28/08 9:54am

jone70

avatar

Byron said:

jone70 said:



It's a great book. I was in speech & drama in high school and did a prose interpretation of one of the chapters--the one where he talks about shame, being 'not poor, just broke', and how he had a crush on the little girl who was clean.

Ooh! I found it online: http://www.angelfire.com/...broke.html

Ironically, I never knew the 'real' title of the book it came from when I was in high school; I thought it was titled "Not Poor Just Broke." My speech coach cut the speech so that you couldn't even tell what race the characters were, so I never even knew Dick Gregory was black! I guess the he thought it would be less controversial in an all white town to not use the n* word, and focus on shame/poverty, which can affect anyone. After college I looked everywhere for that book, "Not Poor, Just Broke" by Dick Gregory and couldn't find it anywhere! lol (Since I didn't know my "not poor, just broke" Dick Gregory was black, I always thought the author of N*gger must be someone different.) Then one day my (then) boyfriend was reading N*gger and told me I should read it because it was a good book. So I did and I found the speech in there! biggrin

falloff lol...Yeah, I was wondering how you pulled that off in your high school from everything you've said about where you grew up lol smile...


That speech coach is also responsible for making me seek out Edna St. Vincent Millay (the murder of Lidice), Elie Weisel (Night), and Sylvia Plath. I think that's pretty frickin' cool, because growing up in a homogenous town of 800, it wasn't that easy to broaden one's perspectives. His name was Jerry and he was a self-proclaimed hippy who called himself "Jer the Bod." lol

The check. The string he dropped. The Mona Lisa. The musical notes taken out of a hat. The glass. The toy shotgun painting. The things he found. Therefore, everything seen–every object, that is, plus the process of looking at it–is a Duchamp.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  Create new topic   Printable version   (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Politics & Religion > The film "Towelhead"